AAcme Agreement Desk Contract management and e-signing. AI reviews every redline; a person signs. Set up your signature
Contracts / Hooli Inc.

Cloud Service Agreement

7 AI calls · 40,540 tokens
$0.03 · 32s model time
Hooli Inc. MSA 4 versions Needs review

Audit trail

Every version, review and decision, oldest first
  1. v1 sent to Hooli Inc.Acme Cloud Inc. · 2026-10-22 11:23:46 UTC
    Acme_Cloud-Service-Agreement_v1.docxv1 · ours OpenDownload
  2. v2 received from Hooli Inc.Hooli Inc. · 2026-10-22 11:23:46 UTC
    Hooli_Cloud-Service-Agreement_v2_redline.docxv2 · theirs OpenDownload
    3 changes from v1 AI recommends: Escalate to legal Full diff
    1 Escalate 2 Push back
    Escalate § 5.5.b removed
    Upon Customer’s request, Provider will delete Customer Content within 60 days.

    What it means

    The customer deleted the clause that said Acme will delete Customer Content within 60 days if the customer asks. Acme no longer has that specific deletion promise.

    Impact on Acme

    The removal cuts one of Acme's obligations, so it looks low-risk. But it leaves a gap on what happens to customer data, including personal data, after a request or at the end of the contract. That gap could matter for GDPR data-processing terms. The customer may also have a reason for the edit that we can't see from the text.

    Safety check: No playbook rule covers this change.
    Sources 80% confident
    Answer: Rejected, our wording restored by Ana Ruiz · 2026-10-22 11:24:02 UTC
    Internal: The deletion duty protects us under GDPR Art. 28(3)(g).
    To Hooli Inc.: We need to keep the deletion clause; it is required for GDPR compliance.
    Push back Payment Period Key term · modified
    30 90 days from the invoice date.

    What it means

    The customer changed the payment deadline from 30 days to 90 days after the invoice date, so they have three times as long to pay.

    Impact on Acme

    Acme would wait up to 90 days for payment, which slows cash flow and delays the point at which it can suspend for non-payment. This is well beyond the 45-day limit in the playbook.

    AI's suggested reply to Hooli Inc.

    Our standard position is that invoices are due within 30 days of the invoice date, and we can agree to up to 45 days if needed.

    Sources 96% confident
    Answer: Countered by Ana Ruiz · 2026-10-22 11:24:02 UTC
    Our wording: 45 days from the invoice date.
    Internal: Finance agreed 45 days as our limit.
    To Hooli Inc.: We can move from 30 to 45 days, which is the longest we offer.
    Push back General Cap Amount Key term · modified
    The Fees paid or payable by Customer in the 12 24 months immediately before the claim.

    What it means

    The customer changed the general liability cap from fees paid or payable in the 12 months before a claim to fees in the 24 months before a claim. This doubles the maximum amount either party can be liable for.

    Impact on Acme

    Acme's maximum exposure for general claims roughly doubles, which is above our accepted limit of 12 months of fees.

    AI's suggested reply to Hooli Inc.

    We can keep the general cap at the fees paid or payable in the 12 months before the claim, and we can discuss a separate higher cap for data breaches of up to 2x that general cap.

    Sources 96% confident
    Answer: Rejected, our wording restored by Ana Ruiz · 2026-10-22 11:24:02 UTC
    Internal: A 24-month cap doubles our exposure.
    To Hooli Inc.: We keep the cap at 12 months of fees, our standard for all customers.
  3. AI review finished: Escalate to legal2026-10-22 11:24:01 UTC
  4. Round closed by Ana Ruiz2026-10-22 11:24:02 UTC

    2 rejected, 1 countered

  5. v3 sent to Hooli Inc.Acme Cloud Inc. · 2026-10-22 11:24:02 UTC
    Acme_Cloud-Service-Agreement_v3.docxv3 · ours OpenDownload
    Cover note to Hooli Inc. Our answer to your changes in v2. Version v3 is attached, unsigned. - Payment Period: we propose new wording, see the attached version. We can move from 30 to 45 days, which is the longest we offer. - General Cap Amount: not accepted; our original wording is restored. We keep the cap at 12 months of fees, our standard for all customers. - § 5.5.b: not accepted; our original wording is restored. We need to keep the deletion clause; it is required for GDPR compliance.
  6. v4 received from Hooli Inc.Hooli Inc. · 2026-10-22 11:24:03 UTC
    Hooli_Cloud-Service-Agreement_v4.docxv4 · theirs OpenDownload
    1 change from v3 AI recommends: Send back to Hooli Inc. Full diff
    1 Push back
    Push back General Cap Amount Key term · modified
    The Fees paid or payable by Customer in the 12 18 months immediately before the claim.

    What it means

    The customer raised the general liability cap from fees paid or payable in the 12 months before a claim to fees in the 18 months before a claim.

    Impact on Acme

    Acme's maximum exposure under the general cap rises by about 50%, beyond what the playbook allows.

    AI's suggested reply to Hooli Inc.

    We can keep the general cap at the fees paid or payable in the 12 months before the claim, and we can discuss a separate higher cap for data breaches of up to 2x the general cap.

    Sources 96% confident

    Your answer

    Still needed: choose accept, reject or counter
    Outcome (required)
  7. AI review finished: Send back to Hooli Inc.2026-10-22 11:24:10 UTC
  8. Close this roundanswer each change, then close

    1 change still needs an answer above.

    If you accepted every change, v4 becomes ready to sign. Otherwise your answers become v5, which goes back to Hooli Inc. unsigned with a cover note.

Clause history

Each changed clause, version by version

Payment Period

  1. v1 · Acme30 days from the invoice date.
  2. v2 · Hooli Inc.30 90 days from the invoice date. push back
  3. v3 · Acme90 45 days from the invoice date. countered by Ana Ruiz

General Cap Amount

  1. v1 · AcmeThe Fees paid or payable by Customer in the 12 months immediately before the claim.
  2. v2 · Hooli Inc.The Fees paid or payable by Customer in the 12 24 months immediately before the claim. push back
  3. v3 · AcmeThe Fees paid or payable by Customer in the 24 12 months immediately before the claim. rejected by Ana Ruiz
  4. v4 · Hooli Inc.The Fees paid or payable by Customer in the 12 18 months immediately before the claim. push back

§ 5.5.b

  1. v1 · AcmeUpon Customer’s request, Provider will delete Customer Content within 60 days.
  2. v2 · Hooli Inc.(removed)escalate
  3. v3 · AcmeUpon Customer’s request, Provider will delete Customer Content within 60 days.rejected by Ana Ruiz